Are exams ‘fair’ on pupils with SEN?

With Ofsted putting pressure on schools to close the gap between pupils with special educational needs (SEN) and their peers, we are asking whether pupils with SEN are at a significant disadvantage come exam time.

Worryingly, there is plenty of evidence to support this argument. In fact, according to the stats, pupils with SEN still fall behind at all stages of their education, and to a dramatic degree.

To illustrate, Department of Education stats for 2012/13 reveal that only 23.4% of pupils with SEN achieved five or more GCSEs at A* to C or the equivalent, compared to 70.4% of pupils with no identified SEN.

Meanwhile, pupils with SEN have the lowest percentage of English Baccalaureate entries with only 10.5% in 2012/13, compared to just under 35% for pupils taken as a whole. This also represents the smallest rise of any group on the entry figures for 2011/12.

So is the problem access arrangements?

Not if you focus on the breadth of provisions.

Incredibly, no fewer than 209,000 access arrangements were delivered in 2012/13, with 92.5% of requests from pupils approved.

These included successful requests for scribes, readers and for exams to be written on coloured paper. Moreover, over 107,000 pupils received extra time in exams of up to 25%, the most common request.

There has been a fair bit of controversy about whether awarding pupils extra time in exams gives them an unfair advantage. But the exam results of pupils with SEN would suggest otherwise.

Is it down to exam preparation?

Perhaps the real issue is not exams themselves but the way in which learning materials are delivered to pupils with SEN.

Take dyslexic pupils. Most teachers now supply learning materials on coloured paper and in dyslexia-friendly font. But does this address the problems that these pupils have with poor processing speeds and the knock-on effect this has on revising and recalling content?

This was brought into focus by a recent study which concluded that learners find note taking harder than playing chess (Piolat, Olive & Kellogg). Just think how that cognitive burden is increased for pupils with dyslexia or other conditions such as ADHD!

In the past, coursework and controlled assessment may have helped level the playing field for these pupils. But as GCSEs and A Levels move from a modular to a linear approach pupils with SEN will now have to revise and retain two years of information.

What’s more, they can now also expect to be penalised for poor spelling, grammar and punctuation in certain GCSE exams.

Are the current access arrangements sufficient to counter all these apparent disadvantages? Or will pupils with SEN continue to fall behind? What is not in doubt is that Ofsted is watching.

Over to you

What do you think? Is there more that can be done to prepare pupils with SEN for exams? Are the current provisions doing the job? We’d love to hear your thoughts.

Alternatively, if you would like a demonstration of how Audio Notetaker can equip teachers to help pupils with SEN, please email adam@sonocent.com

Dig deeper:

Access arrangements in assessment and examinations – The British Dyslexia Association

TES Special Educational Needs Forum

Oct 12

Great to see that students at Rollins College are making good use of their new Sonocent licenses!… https://t.co/GlMRA9opLu

Get started today with our free trial

DOWNLOAD NOW

Sign up to our newsletter

Latest Events

VIEW ALL
  • 16th July 2018 - 4:46 PM

    CONFERENCE | AHEAD 2018

    VIEW
  • 22nd June 2018 - 4:43 PM

    CONFERENCE | ADSHE 2018

    VIEW
  • 13th June 2018 - 4:40 PM

    CONFERENCE | CALL Scotland 2018

    VIEW
  • 12th June 2018 - 3:13 PM

    CONFERENCE |  UCONN Postsecondary Disability Training Institute (PTI) 2018

    VIEW

Sonocent Audio Notetaker free trial

Select the Windows or Mac icon, enter your email address and click ‘Go’

Address

Sonocent Ltd.
D1, Joseph's Well,
Leeds, LS3 1AB, United Kingdom.

Sonocent LLC,
4500 140th Ave North, Suite 101
Clearwater, Florida
33762, USA

Sales

UK: +44 (0) 113 815 0222
sales@sonocent.com
 

USA: +1 727 474 1118 
sales@sonocent-usa.com

Get the latest updates with our newsletter: